Monitor archives:
Copyrighted material

Violence-Torn Haiti Again Becoming U.S. Crisis

by Thalif Deen
 Haiti Article Index

to other articles on Haiti

(IPS) UNITED NATIONS -- The strife-torn Caribbean island of Haiti -- a world away from U.S.-occupied Iraq and Afghanistan -- may turn out to be another political liability both for the United Nations and the United States because of renewed violence, according to UN officials and regional experts.

A sudden wave of violence in the nation in September, reportedly led by supporters of ousted former President Jean-Bertrand Aristide, has threatened to spark a new civil war. A UN force, which was sent to keep the peace, is now in danger of battling rebels, some heavily armed.

The U.S. State Department has issued a travel warning asking U.S. nationals not to visit the country. Last week it asked "non-essential" U.S. diplomats and their families to leave Haiti because of the spiralling violence.

The UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), which is still far short of its total troop strength of 8,000 soldiers, conducted several military operations last week, arresting more than 75 people.

But "if the violence continues," says a UN official, who asked to remain anonymous, "it will surely have an impact on the development and reconstruction of an already-battered economy."

Although the insurgency is unlikely to reach the intensity of Afghanistan or Iraq, he says, it should still be "nipped in the bud."

When Aristide was forced out of power by Washington in February, as U.S.-armed rebels swept towards the capital Port-au-Prince from the country's north, he accused the United States and France of "kidnapping" him and spiriting him out of the country on a U.S.-chartered plane.

Despite strong support for Aristide, the nation's first democratically chosen president, from the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) the United Nations refused to back Aristide.

Reverend Gabriel Odima, president of the Africa Centre for Peace and Democracy, is critical of the UN's failure to stabilize the western hemisphere's poorest nation and rejuvenate its perpetually ailing economy.

"The United Nations has failed the people of Haiti," Odima told IPS. "The UN policy in Haiti lacks the ability to make tough choices, including balancing rhetoric and action on the ground. The policy failed to develop a coherent strategic vision for the people of Haiti."

The 15-member UN Security Council has condemned the fighting and given its backing both to MINUSTAH and to UN Special Envoy for Haiti Juan Gabriel Valdes.

Interim Haitian Prime Minister Gerard Latortue, who was installed in office with the support of the Bush administration, is accusing Aristide, now living in exile in South Africa, of instigating the violence against the government in Port-au-Prince.

Latortue has also accused the South African government of complicity in the violence in Haiti.

Odima said that the Latortue administration should come to terms with reality and stop using South Africa as a scapegoat for the instability in Haiti.

"There is a need for more UN troops to provide temporal stability, but the final solution will depend on the political stability of Haiti," he added.

The UN force currently has a strength of over 3,000 troops, mostly Brazilian. A 125-strong police unit from China arrived in Haiti last week. A further 622 troops from Sri Lanka are expected by the end of October, along with a joint Spanish-Moroccan battalion, but the force is still not expected to reach the targeted 8,000 troops.

Asked about the slow deployment of the UN force, one official said it is purely due to logistical reasons. Some countries contributing troops do not have well-equipped, well-trained soldiers who can be deployed at short notice. As a result, he said, there are long delays in the transfer of troops from home countries to conflict zones.

Brazilian Foreign Minister Celso Amorim was quoted as saying last week that the situation in Haiti was getting worse because the UN force is operating at less than half its strength.

Addressing a meeting at the University of Ulster in Britain on Monday, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan said the United Nations had a peacekeeping mission in Haiti when Aristide returned to power in 1994 with U.S. military backing.

"We trained a new police force," Annan said, "And then we left -- along with other international institutions -- before a viable peace had taken root."

"Now we are back, with much of what we did before swept away -- almost literally, as the recent floods have bared the legacy of years of misrule," Annan said.

The lesson -- "a very important one" -- he added, "is that everyone needs to stay engaged: the Security Council; member states; international non-governmental organizations (NGOs); and of course, the former parties to the conflict, and the people themselves, who are the most essential actors in any peace-building process."

Others see different lessons in Haiti's experience.

"This is what happens when the international community lets the United States destabilize a country: chaos ensues, then more bloodshed," says Matthew Rothschild, editor of 'The Progressive', a left-leaning magazine of investigative reporting and political commentary.

The Bush administration was behind the February "coup" against Aristide he said. "And now the people of Haiti are suffering," adds Rothschild, who has been monitoring developments in the island nation.

"In this instance, as in others, the United Nations bowed to the bully in Washington," Rothschild told IPS.

"Even though Aristide had the strong backing of CARICOM, and even though Aristide himself was begging for UN support, that support was not forthcoming. Instead, the UN Security Council left Aristide to twist in the wind."

That action may come back to haunt the Council, he added. "What's more," said Rothschild, "the international aid community was complicit in the downfall of Aristide and, as result, in the horrors that have come in the coup's wake."

The circumstances under which Aristide left Haiti last February have been in dispute. The United States, which along with France engineered Aristide's departure to the Central African Republic, says the Haitian president left on his own free will.

But Aristide disputes this account, accusing Washington of kidnapping him and forcing him out of the country.

According to diplomatic sources here, both the United States and France, two permanent members of the UN Security Council, also exerted pressure on Caribbean nations to desist from calling for a UN investigation or bringing the issue before the council.

Latortue's government is planning to hold nation-wide elections in 2005, but no dates have been finalised.

In the current conflict, rebels, some of them former soldiers, mercenaries and criminals, are demanding that the old Haitian army be reinstated. They are also accusing UN peacekeepers of doing very little to bring law and order to the destabilised country.

The U.S. State Department has accused the rebels of launching "a systematic campaign to destabilise the interim government and disrupt the efforts of the international community."

"Over the past two weeks, pro-Aristide thugs have murdered policemen, looted businesses and public installations and terrorised civilians," State Department spokesman Richard Boucher told reporters last week.

Compounding the political crisis in Haiti is a humanitarian crisis prompted by last month's tropical storm 'Jeanne' which caused death and destruction. The storm was followed by intense floods in the town of Gonaives where more than 2,000 people died.

Comments? Send a letter to the editor.

Albion Monitor October 20, 2004 (

All Rights Reserved.

Contact for permission to use in any format.