SEARCH
Monitor archives:
Copyrighted material


Taiwan, 2001: This Is What Democracy Looks Like

by Joshua Samuel Brown


READ
Beijing Downplays Impact Of Taiwan Vote
Wong Jyeh
Wong Jyeh deliver her blistering pro-environment, anti nuke speech
It's 1:30 on a sunny Saturday afternoon in mid-November, and a crowd listens rapt to a fiery orator. This is probably what Joe Hill might have sounded like -- had he been a Taiwanese woman. The sharp words of Wong Jyeh, a member of Taiwan's nascent Green Party, would also have earned her a gratuitous police beating and a jail sentence as recently as two decades ago.

Until 1987 Taiwan was a one party dictatorship, ruled by martial law. Political and social activism perceived by the authorities as threatening to the status quo was labeled "treasonous." Rallies of the sort being held by the Taiwan Greens, not to mention the ones being held all over the country by Taiwan's mainstream political parties (including the KMT, or Kuomintang, former martial law masters, whose current party image now offers both reform and a return to traditional values) were inconceivable, unless they were initiated by the ruling party itself. Would-be activists like Ms. Wong had the choice of holding their tongues, or going into exile abroad (either forced or self-imposed).

Even Wong Jyeh's method of delivery would have been verboten before 1987. During martial law rule, Mandarin Chinese was the only language in which political dialogue was conducted, if such dialogue was allowed at all. But in 2001, all of these old rules are part of a distant, long gone dynasty, and Wong Jyeh is free to deliver her blistering pro-environment, anti nuke speech in Taiwanese, Hakka, or even one of the aboriginal languages spoken on the island. Today, Wong Jyeh is speaking a mixture of Taiwanese and Mandarin, with a few English expletives thrown in for good measure.

(Mandarin) "Taiwan Power tells us that that nuclear power is as safe! (Taiwanese) They are liars! Do they think that we've forgotten how they poisoned us in the past? (Mandarin) 'Besides,' they tell us, 'Taiwan needs more power to fuel economic growth' (English) Bullshit!"


Old Fears and New Politics
While the crowd is by no means huge, this should not be taken as a sign that Taiwan is apathetic about the issue of nuclear power. If anything, they're just temporarily burnt out on the subject. Opposition to building the fourth nuclear power plant was one of the platforms of then-candidate Chen Shui-bian (whose election in 2000 marked the first bloodless transfer of power from one group to another in Chinese history). On that subject a little background is in order:

Taiwan's national power company, sometimes called Taipower, had been planning for some time to build a fourth nuclear power plant on the northern tip of the island, a plan that was widely supported by the ruling KMT party. However, many Taiwanese are deeply mistrustful of Taipower's competency; Taiwan's nuclear industry has been beset by numerous accidents and mishaps, including one in 1999 which an overloaded truck full of radioactive waste overturned (the driver was later found to be drunk,) and another this year in which a damaged fuel rod was placed in a reactor (the mistake was noticed in time, and the rod replaced).

However, Taipower's reputation was blackened beyond recovery in 1992 when it was leaked to the press in 1992 that rebar contaminated with Cobalt-60 had been used in the construction of hundereds of buildings throughout Taiwan. The radioactive rebar, made from old pipes removed from Taiwan's second nuclear power and sold as scrap metal, had been discovered by Taipower years earlier, but covered up by the company. Such facts do not sit well with a large segment of Taiwan's electorate, and Chen Shui-bian's gunpoint flip-flop on the issue of building the fourth nuclear power plant (the KMT, still in control of the legislature, had threatened to bring down the government over the issue) angered many of his supporters.

Environmental issues, once ignored, are another hot topic in Taiwanese politics, and great strides have been made in the area in the past few years. Taipei, whose streets were a constant tangled gridlock of taxis, buses, cars and scooters just a few years ago, is one of the few cities in Asia to see a marked improvement in traffic, thanks to the cities new rapid transit system. As the planning, building and opening of the TRTS spanned several administrations, both the DPP and the KMT are quick to take credit for the boost in quality of life that the city has bestowed upon Taipei dwellers.

Taiwan has changed for the better in other key environmental areas as well. Foul air has been made less so by the recent nation-wide switch to unleaded gas, and Taipei's recycling and trash reduction program is proving to be a model system, one that will likely be instituted island-wide. So while Taiwan's environmentalists rightly bemoan the president's forced acquiescence on the construction of the fourth nuclear power plant, they certainly have much to show for their efforts of the last several years.


A shifting political landscape forges new alliancesÉ
At 1:45, the crowd grows larger as marchers from the Democratic Progressive Party, the party of president Chen Shui-bian, join the Greens. Hailing from constituencies closest to the proposed fourth nuclear power plant, the presence of these DPP members shows the fractious, shifting alliances of what some call Asia's most vibrant democracy. Despite calls for party unity, these DPP members are protesting not just the KMT's insistence that the plant be built, but also their own president's perceived kow-tow to KMT pressure to see the project through.

Whereas anti nuclear demonstrations in previous years have drawn crowds estimated to be in the tens of thousands, this rally draws fewer than a thousand people. Nonetheless, it presents an interesting microcosm of Taiwan society as a whole, both ethnically and politically. In addition to DPP members, hardcore Green Party supporters are there in force. These include older Taiwanese, supporters of Taiwan independence who no doubt experienced persecution in the bad old days, University students, who, having come of age in the post martial law era, might still bear childhood memories of being forbidden to speak Taiwanese in their public schools, and a few of Taiwan's minority aboriginal peoples, who have been fighting for years to keep their once pristine lands from being used as the nuclear industry's dumping ground.

It is not surprising to see Taiwan's Greens marching together with the more mainstream DPP. Of Taiwan's major parties, the DPP is considered to be the "pro environment" party. Obviously, the lines often get blurred, and, as Chen Shui-bian found out, having convictions and being able to act on them are two different things. With Taiwan's legislature firmly in the hands of a very hostile opposition, president Chen Shui-bian needs all the friends he can get.


ÉAnd even stranger bedfellows
While a Green / DPP link seems natural, news of another political mating, possibly more insidious and definitely stranger, has recently emerged. According to a report by CNN's Willy Lam, a backroom meeting was recently held between Beijing cadres and KMT stalwarts in which the former pledged to give the latter "political and other kinds" of support to ensure the DPP's defeat at the polls. On the one hand, cooperation between the KMT and the CCP seems unlikely indeed, as the bitter animosity between these two former civil war rivals is legendary. However, both parties seem to be drawn together by a common passion -- the pursuit of wealth. Some say that global capitalism might do what Sun Yat-sen's "Three Principles of the People" could not -- unify China.

That economics is a major factor in the newfound CCP / KMT relationship should come as no surprise. While the DPP's environmental convictions might be considered wishy-washy, nobody questions the pro-business leanings of the KMT. They are, after all, the world's wealthiest political party. While Taiwan's economy has been deteriorating over the past few years, China's economy shows no sign of slowing down. Indeed, many young Taiwanese business school graduates see their future fortunes being made, not in Taiwan, but in Shanghai, Guangzhou and Xiamen. Many KMT candidates are "playing the business card," calling for Taiwan to "hitch its boat to the mainland," and remove all barriers to cross strait trade. This is a message that may hit Taiwanese voters, living through the worst economic downturn in decades, right where it hurts. The KMT has always shown great aptitude in making money in any situation, right down to looting every bank they could on their retreat from the mainland in 1949. And since both the KMT and the CCP have, for years, professed the same goal -- a reunified China, including Taiwan, marching together under one flag. Under whose flag, and to what tuneÉ therein lies the difficulty.

The possibility of this sort of partnership is the stuff of nightmares of many of Taiwan's pro-independence activists. Hunted as "splittists" for years under martial law, these activists can have no illusions about the difficulties they'd face in a post-unification Taiwan. But even politically moderate Taiwanese, only now beginning to savor the fruits of democracy, might look with suspicion upon a Taiwanese political party seemingly too eager to jump into bed with the CCP.


Playing the terrorist card
At 2:00, the rally begins moving west down Hsinyi road. Headed by Green Party legislative candidate Kao Chen-yeh, the Green / DPP supporters marched with banners and signs proclaiming their firm opposition to the plant. At 2:15, the marchers stop, and Wong Jyeh delivers another speech -- this time, directed at the American Institute in Taiwan (The USA's defacto embassy -- America does not maintain "formal" relations with Taiwan).

This may seem an unlikely place in which to air such grievances. First, the American government has little say in the internal energy policy of the Taiwanese government, and second, it's Saturday, and the building is closed.

So where is the American connection?

The answer, or at least the immediate one, concerns the events of September 11 in New York City. Wong Jyeh speaks again to the crowd, to the empty embassy building and the police guarding it.

(Mandarin) "After the events of 9/11, can we afford not to consider the possibility that Mainland China would attack a nuclear power plant? (Taiwanese)Are we crazy? Of course, the government tells us, 'don't worry, the Mainland would not dare to attack a power plant' (English) More bullshit!"
nuke protest model

While she speaks, marchers hold aloft a paper mache model of the proposed fourth Nuke plant, but one with an airplane sticking out of its ruptured dome. The words "Air China" are written on the plane, and a Chinese flag painted on the tail (possibly to avoid confusion with "China Air, which is a Taiwanese carrier). The very fact that the writing is in English indicated that this segment of the rally was meant to elicit American sympathy.

There are no signs, and no rhetoric, directed at the more obvious American / nuclear connection -- that the reactor for the plant would be provided by Westinghouse, an American company.

"We do not wish to single out any American company," One marcher says "Rather, our aim is to appeal directly to the American government to apply pressure to our own. Formerly, warfare of this sort -- civilian airplanes being used against civilian targets -- was unthinkable. But now, we hope that America, having experienced this tragedy at home, will be sympathetic to our fear that Mainland China might target our own nuclear plants."

To some, the Green's strategy of linking an anti-nuclear protest to the tragedy of 9/11 may seem like simply a cheap way to get extra publicity. However, the attack has special significance to the Taiwanese, who have long felt that America's formidable military might deter the Mainland from making good on its many threats to bring Taiwan back into the fold by any means necessary. But the events of 9/11 -- a devastating attack on American soil, perpetrated by a vastly inferior opponent -- have made many Taiwanese think twice about their protector's invulnerability. America, once a seeming fortress, has been rendered "Touchable". At best, some Taiwanese see Americas military being stretched too far to be able to protect Taiwan, should push come to shove. At worst, some see a possibility of a "Czechoslovakia" scenario, in which Taiwan is used as a bargaining chip to secure Chinese support for American military interests.

"America has always been Taiwan's friend, even while paying lip-service to China," says one elderly man, who identified himself as a "pragmatic supporter of Taiwanese independence." "But everything has changed now. If America needs to call on China's help to fight Bin Laden, China will certainly demand concessions. Many people worry about how that could weaken America's resolve to defend Taiwan."


The die-in
By 3:00, the streets in front of America's only official presence in Taiwan are again open to traffic. The marchers spent only about a half an hour in front of AIT, and the peaceful rally presented a sharp contrast to those held in front of American embassies and interests in other parts of Asia. The twenty-or-so policemen sent to keep order stood politely and listened, and the specially appointed embassy guard pacing in front of AIT's locked door kept the barrel of his machine gun pointed downward. The marchers then headed in a reasonably ordered fashion over to the headquarters of the KMT, Which was to be their terminal station, literally and figuratively, where the protest ended in a choreographed "die in" designed to simulate the effects of acute radiation poisoning. But nobody actually died. Their point having been made, the protesters were able to leave, free to attend future protests (or not), free to offer their support to (or withhold it from) the parties and causes of their choice in the future.

To some Asia watchers, used to the choreographed riots seen so often in South Korea, the dramatic and often bloody changes in regimes in the Philippines (in which successor arrests predecessor,) and the anarchy which engulfs Indonesia in sporadic bursts, Taiwanese democracy might seem dull, and the marcher's tactics, hopelessly naive.

Protest marches and die-ins make for good press, but nobody in their right mind would believe that the KMT -- a politcal machine with over half a century of consilidated power and billions of dollars at its disposal -- could be forced from power by ballot alone.

Two weeks later, that's exactly what happened; on December 1, Taiwanese voters hit the polls in droves. When the votes were tallied, the KMT, once Taiwan's sole legal party, found themselves reduced to minority party status in a country that they once ruled with an iron grip.


Joshua Samuel Brown's previous MONITOR article was Confessions Of A Sweatshop Inspector

Comments? Send a letter to the editor.

Albion Monitor December 8, 2001 (http://www.monitor.net/monitor)

All Rights Reserved.

Contact rights@monitor.net for permission to use in any format.